Hopes that the extreme caution with which the McCanns have
previously discussed the disappearance of their daughter might be
moderated in
Madeleine
take something of an early blow: in the acknowledgements section
M/S McCann credits, in addition to the normal celebrity quotient of
editors, agents and publicists, no fewer than four lawyers (including
Mr. E
"Expunge"
Smethurst and Adam Tudor of Carter Ruck) and thanks them not merely for
their assistance but for their part in
completing the book.
They may, of course, just have been
refreshing her memory of the litigation that the couple has been
involved in since 2008; or their collaboration may have taken a
different form. Whichever it is their silent presence in the gap between
page and reader suggests that both newsworthy revelations and glaring
inconsistencies are going to be in short supply. Nevertheless for
students of the case the book is a worthwhile read, first and least
valuably as a memoir, secondly as a historical source and lastly as a
self-portrait.
Regarding the first, as a simple
celebrity-cum-misery memoir it isn't bad at all. M/S McCann eschews the
use of a ghost writer and, despite what we've read of her execrable
"diaries", knows how to put a sentence together. The early pages,
indeed, are the best and least self-conscious in the book as she writes
lightly and without sentimentality of her Liverpool background and
childhood.
Her descriptions of student life
and the early years of her relationship with Gerry McCann are less
spontaneous, singing more of the celebrity literary agents' demand for
background colour than any strong desire to share her memories. Life in
New Zealand and the Netherlands floats by with almost no comment on the
culture or population of the two countries, in contrast to her tale of
attempts to have children which, as an erstwhile obstetrician, she
recounts in considerable detail. About medicine as a vocation she has
nothing to say and none of her patients are ever portrayed, anonymously
or otherwise. She writes that she had no particular interest in a
medical career ? it was more a matter of deciding between the various
opportunities that her undoubted academic ability and determination (and
she is modest about these) offered her. With the birth of her children
the conventional narrative of early ambitions achieved and human
happiness attained is complete. Despite the unoriginality of the tale ?
which is the fault of the industry, not M/S McCann ? this is an adult
speaking, not a celebrity creation, comfortable with her judgements and
decisions and, up to a certain point, confident in her identity.
Thus the curtain is raised on the
drama the reader is most interested in: between May and October 2007 M/S
McCann suffered the loss of her daughter, became a world-wide "misery
celebrity" with unrestricted access to the corridors of the great and a
developing taste for travel in private jets and then, in an altogether
Hitchcockian twist, was accused of involvement in the disappearance of
her own child before finding eventual sanctuary in her homeland. This
transformation in her fortunes was matched, at giddying speed, by her
portrayal in the media ? from glamorous but stoical heroine to a rag
doll stripped of all privacy and dignity in a matter of weeks. How she
and her husband handled these switchback changes in their fortunes
together with the public's perception of events provides the heart of
the book, with the police investigation into their possible guilt
provoking the most strongly felt and dramatic writing in the whole work.
Soon after their return to the UK
the drama is essentially over. The pathos of Clarence Mitchell's press
conference in front of their Rothley home, with the pair standing mute
in his long shadow like a pair of dejected, sagging, criminals, remains
sharp in the memory. Behind the scenes, however, and starting with a
three and a half hour legal defence meeting on the day they landed in
England, one of the most expensive and powerful legal teams in modern
British history was being assembled. Given the paucity of the Portuguese
police case against the pair ? a large box full of loose ends ? the
defence effort seems disproportionate to any actual danger that
threatened them and the tension inevitably falls away. What follows
becomes something of a public report in which her campaigning work in
child protection and her various interviews and public appearances are
described in considerable, not to say tedious, detail. Meanwhile the
exhausting, exhaustive and at times hysterically absurd campaign to find
her daughter uncovers absolutely nothing, nada, not a single lead.
Personalities are naturally
described in limited ? i.e. non-existent ? depth according to the
conventions of the genre. It is not easy for it to be otherwise when
writing about living people who may still have a part, however obscure,
to play; Goncalo Amaral, unsurprisingly, is the subject of scorn and
bewilderment at his supposed lack of human feeling and his
determination, according to Kate McCann, to stop the world searching for
Madeleine. Little is said, though no doubt much could be written, about
the various chancers and scoundrels who offered their services ? at a
price ? to help locate the child.
Despite the collaborating lawyers
and the ever-present sensation of a text having being under microscopic
scrutiny before being allowed to reach the paying reader there are one
or two minor surprises. The extremely active role of the grandly named
but only recently founded International Family Law Group in the parents'
affairs in the early days, including their part in the establishment of
the controversial family fund, their pressing suggestions that Madeleine
should be made a ward of court and their introduction of some serious
mercenaries-cum- private investigators from the Control Risks group, is
bound to raise questions about their judgement. The IFLG was also
intimately involved in the couple's ill-fated legal move to lay hands on
Leicester police files on the case in summer 2008. M/S McCann gives a
brief extract from the (previously confidential) Leicester police
response to the action which stated, essentially, that there was "no
clear evidence" to eliminate the couple from involvement in the child's
disappearance and therefore they would not entrust them with the
requested files. The LP position remains unchanged: the files are still
denied to the parents.
M/S McCann's feelings of having
been abandoned by British "authorities" ? she doesn't really do the
separation of powers thing ? once she is made arguida are revealed as
the mirror image of Amaral's sense of abandonment by his own chiefs,
though no doubt some readers will see deep currents beneath the
apparently obvious truth of her comments. She explicitly denies any
premonitions about Madeleine's well-being in Praia da Luz ? somewhat
surprising given the equally explicit statements of some of her friends
on the question. And new to me, at least, is the Portuguese police claim
that a witness saw her and her husband carrying something in a large
black bag on the evening of May 3.
The conclusion of the book exhibits
a certain tension. The celebrity/misery memoir rules demand an upbeat
ending; M/S McCann is OK with that but is uneasy about how the public
might judge her if she is, well, too happy, given the circumstances of a missing child, fate
unknown. Still, she manages it well enough, just as she manages the
burden of her guilt. The knowledge that she is a stronger and more able
woman now than she was a couple of years ago helps her, she says, to
"shake off" a little of that guilt. Such questions as the real meaning
of guilt, together with Kate McCann's Catholic conception of it, take us
away from the celebrity memoir and on to the much more complex area of
Madeleine's value as a
true self-portrait, a subject that we will soon turn to. For the moment
we can leave her with her book successfully completed, staring
sensitively into the distance, alone ? apart from the presence at her
side of Bill Scott-Kerr, Sally Gaminara, Janine Giovanni and Alison
Barrow, all of Transworld publishers, Neil Blair and Christopher Little,
her agents, the aforesaid quartet of lawyers and her friend Claudia from
the Portuguese PR company Lift Consulting ? sad but beautiful, stronger
for her suffering. Cue music and credits. |