As Lord Justice
Leveson ends the first part of his inquiry into the press, and amid a
new wave of News International arrests, we examine the 40 days of
testimony
|
Hugh Grant at the Leveson inquiry.
Photograph: BBC |
The whole thing began with Hugh Grant arriving at the high court in a
blaze of camera flashes – and ended with the Daily Mail editor Paul
Dacre arguing over what the actor had said. In between it took up 40
days, with victims of crime, arrested journalists, a multi-millionaire
author and every national daily newspaper editor among the 184 witnesses
in court 73. Its presiding judge was shown pictures of a topless Carla
Bruni and sent confidential material on the truth – or otherwise – of
deleted voicemails on Milly Dowler's phone. It is the Leveson inquiry
into press standards, and after all that, the team have only completed
part one, which ended on Friday. The others concern relations with the
police, politicians and ethics. Lord Justice Leveson says he does not
want to end up a "footnote in some professor of journalism's analysis of
21st century history". Amid the blizzard of evidence, what has he
learned?
1 There is a McCann problem
Leveson started in November with evidence from Grant, and complaints
from the father of a 7/7 victim that the inquiry had been "hijacked by
celebrities". However, it was the evidence of Kate and Gerry McCann,
pictured, that had the most impact – the family whose search for their
daughter in 2007 became a press ordeal a year later when they were
accused of killing her. A halting Kate talked of "journalists [who] said
we stored her body in a freezer"; photographers jumping out of bushes
and shaking their car to get a startled look; and how she "felt totally
violated" when the News of the World published her diaries without
permission. Richard Desmond's Express group paid £550,000 in damages,
and the News of the World £125,000. Their testimony raised a simple
issue: what happens when the next ordinary family is in the eye of the
media storm? In the weeks afterwards, Leveson repeatedly talked about
the need for ordinary people to obtain redress.
2 Celebrities have feelings too
Steve Coogan, the actor and comedian, complained that he had been
tricked into giving information about where his children were schooled
by a Sunday Times interviewer; and what he thought was a private
conversation was published. JK Rowling, pictured, the Harry Potter
author, gave passionate evidence about keeping her children from being
photographed, and was also distressed discussing a "vehement" Sunday
Mirror article, which said her husband was "at the beck and call of his
obscenely rich wife".
3 Plotting over new regulator has begun
The Press Complaints Commission is dead. It died before hearings began,
when Dacre gave an electric speech in which he attacked almost everybody
else in the media for causing the crisis, before conceding that a
reformed regulator would need an "ombudsman" to investigate scandals,
summon editors and in cases of the "most extreme malfeasance" impose
fines. Leveson took the point, saying repeatedly that the PCC had
failed. His powers are, however, limited. With everybody wanting to keep
self-regulation, he cannot impose. Nevertheless, he seemed surprised
when Lord Hunt, pictured, the new PCC chairman, indicated that the new
body should have a "standards and compliance" arm and a "complaints and
mediation" arm – and newspapers should be bound to membership by signing
five-year contracts with the body.
4 There is also a Desmond problem
Richard Desmond's Express and Star titles are no longer members of the
PCC, creating a headache for those wanting a tougher form of
self-regulation. It did not help that Desmond, pictured, performed a
comedy turn in January, blaming the PCC for failing to stop his
newspapers writing incorrectly about the McCanns, describing it as a
"useless organisation run by people who wanted tea and biscuits, and
phone hackers". It appeared there was no way to force him to join,
although there was talk of incentives, such as taking away VAT exemption
on non-PCC member titles. Hunt surprised everybody by saying that he
could bring Desmond along without using the law.
5 There's a way to go on hacking
It was the problem the inquiry dared not address, and for a good reason:
the ongoing criminal inquiry. Sue Akers, the deputy assistant
commissioner in charge of the phone hacking investigation, did say in
February that 829 identifiable individuals had been hacked. The
situation also created the curiosity in which several News of the World
journalists, who had been arrested on suspicion of hacking, gave
evidence to the inquiry, including Neil Wallis, pictured, a former
deputy editor, Neville Thurlbeck, a former chief reporter, and Ian
Edmondson, a former news editor. Leveson will return to hacking in phase
two, which will begin whenever any criminal trials conclude.
6 Journalists want a new deal on libel
Leveson floated the idea of a "libel and privacy tribunal" in January.
Debating with Lionel Barber, pictured, the editor of the Financial
Times, he suggested that there would be a role in the new system of
press self-regulation for "some sort of arbitral system for speedy
resolution of privacy claims, potentially small libel claims", because
the costs of bringing actions and defending cases was unnecessarily
high. The idea quickly proved popular on Fleet Street – where editors
have long complained of the six and seven figure cost of libel and
privacy actions – as a possible win for an industry that otherwise will
have to bow to greater regulation.
7 Editors fear political control
James Harding, pictured, the editor of the Times, and John Witherow, of
the Sunday Times, used similar arguments in January to oppose a "Leveson
act" – statutory regulation. Harding said that could lead to politicians
interfering with regulation. Witherow said that Alastair Campbell's
reaction to the BBC reporting of the Iraq war dossier was an example of
what happens when the government feels it controls the media.
8 Misdeeds are still being uncovered
The inquiry travelled over much familiar ground. But Harding was
recalled in February for an uncomfortable hour in which he had to go
over a single incident of computer hacking in 2008, by Patrick Foster, a
former Times reporter, to identify a blogger – and his newspaper's
decision to publish a story about the individual even after it knew how
the information emerged. There remains a question also for Colin Myler,
pictured, the last editor of the News of the World, over the decision to
publish Kate McCann's diary. Myler said that he thought Edmondson had
obtained the McCanns' permission. But he was contradicted by Edmondson
last week, who said that Myler had instructed him to tell the McCanns of
their intentions in very "woolly terms" so they would not take action to
prevent publication.
9 Privacy is battling it out with the public interest
Ryan Giggs, the footballer, did not attend, but Garry Flitcroft did. The
former Blackburn Rovers player, who failed in the high court to stop the
Sunday People revealing an extramarital affair in 2002, said that
"there's no reason why my private life should be in the public interest"
and he attributed his father's suicide to depression brought on by the
coverage. Not every journalist agreed, with many from the tabloids
talking of the need to expose "hypocrisy" if a celebrity was living a
"false public image". Ian Hislop, the editor of Private Eye said that
reporting about sex can be in the public interest. "It is wrong to
suggest that there can never be a public interest in a person's sexual
relationship. It all depends on the circumstances," he said. The inquiry
did not dwell on such differences, and it was not until Dacre, pictured,
gave evidence last week that he offered one solution – a commission to
define "public interest".
10 Pippa Middleton is in demand
Pippa Middleton did not need to turn up to contribute. Paul Silva, the
picture editor of the Daily Mail, said that the title received up to 400
images of her daily, because photographers snap her whenever she leaves
home. He said he only used pictures of her at public events or where
permission had been given. There was much evidence critical of paparazzi
photographers, with Sienna Miller, pictured, capturing it most simply.
"Take away the cameras," she said, "and you've got a pack of men chasing
a woman." |